Collectivevs.Lettuce

Collective vs. Lettuce

Collective pairs its own AI-backed software with a team of experts who review the work, and Collective works with the bank you already use. Lettuce is software-first automation built around its own business bank account.

4.7Trustpilot· 650+ reviews

12,000 solopreneurs trust Collective

Potential yearly savings
“Collective provided a structure for business management where I lacked that knowledge. It’s nice to know that you have someone who’s got your back.”
Vincent Nguyen
Data Consultant

Collective is featured in

Bloomberg logo
Yahoo logo
Forbes logo
TechCrunch logo
Real Simple logo
PYMNTS logo
Axios Pro logo
The comparison

Which is right for your business?

Here's how the standard plans compare, based on each company's pricing page as of November 5, 2026.

Trustpilot ratingVerified customer reviews
Collective
4.7/5 · 650+ reviews
Lettuce
3.8/5 · 89
Business set up
Collective

Business set up for a new LLC or existing entity review, EIN, operating agreement, registered agent services and compliance monitoring. S Corp plan adds S Corp election filing.

Lettuce

LLC set up, business name validation and EIN registration. Pro adds the S Corp election and free migration if already incorporated.

Banking
Collective

Connect your existing business bank and credit accounts. Keep your current bank, no switching required.

Lettuce

Includes a Lettuce business bank account and debit card. Business income must land in the Lettuce account.

Bookkeeping
Collective

AI-backed software imports and categorizes transactions, then a real bookkeeper reviews and reconciles your books every month, with monthly financial reports.

Lettuce

Automated expense tracking with card sync and reports. No human bookkeeper review listed on Lettuce's pricing page.

Payroll
Collective

S Corp plan: reasonable salary support plus payroll for you and your contractors, powered by Gusto.

Lettuce

Pro only: reasonable salary management and monthly payroll. Grow: contractor payments with ACH.

Invoicing
Collective

Invoicing with Stripe client payments.

Lettuce

Invoicing on Grow and Pro.

Registered agent
Collective

Registered agent coverage for your home state.

Lettuce

Not offered.

Tax returns
Collective

LLC plan: Individual Tax Return and state entity-level taxes. S Corp plan: Business Tax Return (Individual Tax Return available as an add-on).

Lettuce

Pro only: business entity tax prep and filing. Personal tax filing costs extra.

Support
Collective

Email support and an AI assistant. S Corp plan adds a dedicated account manager.

Lettuce

AI assistant and support team. Pro adds live webinars. No dedicated account manager listed on Lettuce's pricing page.

Pricing

What does each actually cost?

A solution for every stage, deductible for every business.

CollectiveCollective
Plan
Price
Advisor
LLC Tier
For single-member LLCs
$199/mo
Included*
S Corp Tier
For S Corp election
$349/mo
Included*
Every plan also includes an embedded AI assistant, bookkeeping reviewed by humans, payroll, business tax prep & filing, registered agent, and personalized invoicing.*Advisor access scales by plan: an on-demand expert team on LLC, a dedicated advisor on S Corp.
LettuceLettuce
Plan
Price
Advisor
Grow
Solos starting out earning $40–69K; no S Corp management
$49/mo for new accounts, a promotional rate (regularly $99)
Not included
Pro
Solos and existing S Corps earning $70K+
$299/mo billed monthly
Not included
Pro + Healthcare
Pro plus healthcare premiums, in states Lettuce supports
$299+/mo billed monthly
Not included
**Lettuce leads with a 24/7 AI assistant plus a support team. Its pricing page does not list a dedicated account manager; confirm current support details with Lettuce.
Did you know

Lettuce's automation runs through its own bank account. Business income lands there so Lettuce can split salary and distributions and handle payroll and taxes. Collective takes a different approach: Collective's own AI-backed software connects to the bank accounts you already use, and a bookkeeper reviews and reconciles your books each month. The result is accurate books, faster, without changing banks.

Collective is AI plus real experts. Always a person to call.

Experts plus software, or software-first.

Collective

Collective: experts + software

Daily

Your transactions sync from your bank and our in-house team ensures they're captured on your books.

At tax time

Our tax pros prepare and file your business tax return. Personal returns are available as an add-on.

Whenever you need extra support

Our AI agent is available 24/7, with real human support on standby.

Lettuce

Lettuce: software-first

Every day

AI auto-categorizes transactions inside the Lettuce bank account.

At tax time

Business tax prep and filing on Pro; personal 1040 is an extra $500/yr.

When something comes up

24/7 AI assistant and a support team. No dedicated account manager listed.

Collective is for you if…

You want a real person in your corner who already knows your situation when you reach out.

You want flexibility, not a platform that makes you bank their way.

You'd rather send a quick message than figure out how to phrase a question for a chatbot.

You don't need to understand every tax form. You just need support from someone who does.

You want a credentialed professional to prepare your return and stand behind it.

You're done managing five tools to run one business and want one place that handles it.

A closer look

Collective's plans start at $199/month (LLC) and $349/month (S Corp), with monthly bookkeeping reviewed by a real person included. Lettuce's Grow plan is $49/month for new accounts (regularly $99), but it doesn't include S Corp management. For S Corp, Lettuce's Pro plan is $299/month billed monthly.

Collective keeps your books with software and people, using the bank accounts you already have. Lettuce tracks expenses inside its own app and asks that business income land in the Lettuce bank account.

At Collective, you connect your existing business bank and credit accounts. If you're still choosing a bank, compare business bank accounts for solopreneurs. Collective's own AI-backed software imports transactions and suggests categories as they come in. A bookkeeper then reviews the work, flags items like personal charges or duplicates, and reconciles the books each month. See how bookkeeping for self-employed entrepreneurs works at Collective.

Clean monthly books give you a clear read on your business year-round, not only at tax time. Lettuce says you don't have to give up your current bank and can move money back anytime.

Both platforms run payroll through Gusto and help owners with S Corp status set a reasonable salary.

Payroll is how the potential self-employment tax savings of an S Corp election are realized. On Collective's S Corp plan, our team helps you understand what a reasonable salary looks like for your role, then runs payroll at the salary you decide on. After salary, the rest of the profit can be taken as owner distributions.

Collective payroll is flexible. Choose automated monthly runs or a setup tailored to you, including one-click manual runs when income fluctuates. Collective payroll covers your own salary, W2 employees and contractors, and our team helps you transition payroll from another provider. Lettuce doesn't disclose on their website if payroll frequency is customizable.

Collective's team of experts build your estimates and returns from the books our AI and bookkeeping team keep for you. Lettuce automates tax set-aside and, on Pro, pays estimated taxes and files the business return.

Quarterly estimates spread the year's tax bill across four payments. With Collective's tax support, we help calculate them from your current profit, and you make the payments yourself.

Collective's LLC plan includes a basic Individual Tax Return. The S Corp plan includes the annual Business Tax Return, a separate filing from the Individual Tax Return. For members with S Corp status, the Individual Tax Return is an add-on. You review and approve before anything is filed. Lettuce Pro includes business entity tax filing, with personal tax filing for an extra fee.

Collective pairs an AI assistant with a human team you can reach, and the S Corp plan adds a dedicated account manager. Lettuce offers its LettuceHead AI assistant 24/7 plus the Lettuce support team.

Lettuce Pro adds live webinars.

Collective is a good fit if you want people reviewing your books and preparing your returns alongside software. Lettuce can be a good fit if you'd rather have automation and banking in one app.

  • You want a bookkeeper reviewing and reconciling your books each month.
  • You'd like to keep your current business bank accounts.
  • You have an LLC and want a basic Individual Tax Return included in your plan.
  • You have S Corp status, or are considering it, and want payroll set up around how you earn.
  • You want a dedicated account manager (S Corp plan).

Lettuce can be a good fit if you want a built-in business bank account that sets taxes aside automatically, or a lower starting price while you're new.

Pricing and features for both Collective and Lettuce are accurate as of June 2026 and based on publicly available information. Lettuce plans referenced: Grow $49/mo (promotional; regularly $99/mo), Pro $299/mo, Pro + Healthcare from $299/mo, all billed monthly; Lettuce requires the use of its own bank account, and its pricing page does not list a dedicated account manager. Comparison reflects standard plan inclusions and may not capture every promotional offer or recent change. Savings figures are illustrative estimates based on average member outcomes and are not a guarantee. Collective is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or sponsored by Lettuce; all product and company names are the property of their respective owners.

© 2026 Collective. Transparent pricing. No surprise fees.